Ref. | Model | Modality | Dataset | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|
[41] | Caffe | DBT1 | 2D mamo = 1864, 3D mamo = 339, | Mean ROI sesitivity, suspicous lesions(conventional methods = 0.8320 + \(-0.040\), |
 |  |  | Suspicious lesions = 328, malignant lesions = 115 | DL = 0.893 + \(-0.003\)), malignant lesions(conventional methods = 0.852 + \(-0.065\), |
 |  |  |  | DL = 0.930 + \(-0.046\)) |
[43] | AlexNet/DCNN | DM/DBT | Dataset = 2192 | AUC (before pruning = 0.88, after pruning = 0.90) |
[44] | VGG19 | SM/DM/DBT | Dataset patients = 76, lesions = 78 | AUC = 0.89 + \(-0.04\) classification of malignant and benign |
[45] | ResNet | DM/DBT | Patients = 62,417, exams = 198,201, images = 830,450 | ROC AUC = 0.9 |
[46] | VGG16 | DM/DBT | Patients = 441, views = 927, CC = 460, ML = 4, MLO = 463 | Malignant classification (AUC = 0.91, ACC = 95.1%, SEN = 70.8%, SPE = 98.9%) |
[47] | 3D-DCNN | DBT | Patients = 40, reconstructed volume = 160 | Avg AUC = 0.847 + \(-0.012\) |
[48] | DCaRBM/DCNN | DBT | Images = 87, breast/volume = 87, image slices = 5040 | AUC = 0.87, ACC = 86.81, SPE = 87.5, SEN = 86.6 |
[50] | AlexNet (2D-CNN) | DM/DBT | Data = 3705 | auROC = 0.854 |
[49] | CNN (AlexNet) | DM/DBT | Data = 3290 | auROC = 0.73 |
[51] | CNN (ImageNet) | DM/DBT | Patients = 1124 | ACC = 0.91, F1 = 0.91, Precision = 0.93, Recall = 0.88 AUC = 0.97 |
[52] | ResNet-34 | SM/DM/DBT | Exams = 207,776 | Four class acc = 82.2, four class macro AUC = 0.95, |
 |  |  |  | Binary acc = 91.1, binary AUC = 0.971 |
[53] | EMPIRE/FBP | DBT | Patients = 374 | pAUC = 0.880 |
[54] | ResNet-50 | DM/DBT | Cases = 63,798 | AUC = 0.95 |
[55] | Faster RCNN/DCNN | DBT | Cases = 89 | ROC AUC = 0.96 |
[56] | 3D-Mask-RCNN | DBT | Cases = 364 | Lesion based mass detection (sensitivity = 90% with 0.8 FPs), |
 |  |  |  | Breast based mass detection (sensitivity = 90% with 0.83 FPs) |
[57] | U-Net | DBT | Data = 87 | SEN = 0.869, ACC = 0.871, AUC = 0.859 |
[58] | DenseNet | DBT | Patients = 5060, studies = 5610, DBT volumes = 22,032 | Sensitivity = 65% at 2 FPS |
[60] | Faster RCNN | DBT | Patients = 68, DBT volume = 265 | mean true positive fraction, typical AD 0.6 + \(-0.05\) |